I will make no apologies. Jimmy Eat World is one of my all-time favorite bands, and as such, I went into this particular disc with a bit of a bias. Despite the billing order, J.E.W. starts off the disc with a rarity called "The Most Beautiful Things," which is quite good, and likens back to the Clarity/Bleed American days... Which makes sense, because it was released a year after Clarity and a year before Bleed American. The song has a hard-hitting Chorus, and some great vocal lines. The second song is "No Sensitivity," which is the only song I had heard off this disk before I bought it, and would have been worth the price by itself. This is one of my all-time favorite Jimmy tracks, and I'm stoked to own it. the guitars slide through a slick arrangement, and the rhythm section keeps the song flowing nicely, but the real centerpiece is the vocals, with cutting lyrics and a passionate performance. The third song is an early demo-version of "Cautioners" which ended up in a more polished form on Bleed American. This is a great song, but the album version is more enjoyable. I think there might even be some phase problems on the drums... Next up Jebediah comes on the scene, and is completely tolerable, and even a little catchy, if it wasn't for the singer's highly nasal voice, poor pronunciation, and lyrical clumsiness. the vocal lines are pretty catchy in themselves, and at his best, he sounds a bit like the lead singer of The Vines, but for the most part, his voice and the lyrics completely fair to make these songs more than passively worthwhile. All in all, this is a fun little disc, and worth the money if you are a Jimmy fan. Or a Jebediah fan, although I can't say I've ever encountered one...
6/10